In searches for gotham steel air fryer reviews, this Gotham Steel Crisper Tray stands out as an oven accessory rather than a countertop appliance.
Its raised mesh basket and catch pan are designed to support air circulation while collecting drips and crumbs below.
Gotham Steel Tray Review Summary
The quick verdict

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in an oven or convection oven without adding a standalone air fryer.
- Two piece construction pairs a raised mesh basket with a solid catch pan.
- Round set measures 13.12 inches across and is intended for many standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air fryer models.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating in a copper colored finish.
- Basket and pan are described as dishwasher safe for easier cleanup.
Pros
- Elevated mesh design leaves room for air to circulate around food.
- Catch pan helps collect grease and crumbs instead of letting them fall directly onto the oven.
Consider before buying
- The 13.12 inch round footprint may not suit every oven or rack layout; measure the usable space before buying.
- It relies on an oven or compatible convection oven, so it does not provide the independent heating and capacity of a standalone air fryer.
Read the full review summary
The two piece setup combines a copper colored, nonstick coated aluminum pan with a reinforced mesh basket.
The basket holds food above the solid tray, leaving space for hot air to circulate around it; the pan catches grease and crumbs during air frying, baking, roasting, or reheating.
Its round 13.12 inch footprint is intended for most standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air fryer models.
That makes it worth considering for cooks who already have a suitable oven and want a dedicated crisping surface, provided the diameter fits their cooking space.
The buying factors
Gotham Steel Tray Scorecard
Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.
Airflow-focused design
The raised mesh basket lets air circulate around food while the pan collects drips beneath it.
Cooking versatility
The set is intended for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating in an oven or convection oven.
Compact oven fit
The round 13.12 inch set is designed for many standard racks and smaller convection ovens, though buyers should measure their usable space.
Cleanup convenience
The coated pan and basket are described as dishwasher safe, and the lower tray catches crumbs and grease.
Coating considerations
The titanium and ceramic nonstick coating supports food release; buyers should follow the care instructions to preserve the surface.
Standalone appliance replacement
It adds an oven cooking surface but depends on a compatible oven and does not include a separate heating appliance.
Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Tray
- Two piece construction pairs a raised mesh basket with a solid catch pan.
- Round set measures 13.12 inches across and is intended for many standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air fryer models.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating in a copper colored finish.
- Basket and pan are described as dishwasher safe for easier cleanup.
- Designed for oven air fry, bake, roast, and reheat settings.
- The solid pan below the basket catches grease and crumbs during cooking.
Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Tray
Pros
- Elevated mesh design leaves room for air to circulate around food.
- Catch pan helps collect grease and crumbs instead of letting them fall directly onto the oven.
- Can serve several oven cooking tasks, including air frying, roasting, baking, and reheating.
- Coated basket and tray are described as dishwasher safe.
Consider before buying
- The 13.12 inch round footprint may not suit every oven or rack layout; measure the usable space before buying.
- It relies on an oven or compatible convection oven, so it does not provide the independent heating and capacity of a standalone air fryer.
- The coated surfaces call for care consistent with nonstick cookware; check the included care guidance before choosing cleaning tools.
Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Tray?
Good fit
Consider it if you already cook with an oven or convection oven and want a raised basket for smaller batches of fries, wings, or vegetables.
The mesh-over-pan arrangement is useful when you want air to reach food from below while drips and loose crumbs collect on a separate surface.
It also makes sense for cooks who prefer one accessory that can move among air fry, bake, roast, and reheat tasks.
Check the tray diameter against your oven interior and rack spacing, then consider how much food you typically cook in a single layer.
The coated aluminum construction and dishwasher safe design may appeal if easy release and cleanup are priorities. Follow the care directions for the coating, and use oven mitts when handling the hot tray.
Who should skip it
Look elsewhere if you need a self-contained air fryer with its own heating system, controls, and cooking chamber. This set is designed to work inside an oven.
It may not suit kitchens with limited oven space or buyers who need a rectangular tray. Confirm that the round 13.12 inch footprint fits the rack and leaves enough room for your other cookware.
How the Gotham Steel Tray Fits Oven Air Frying
The raised basket changes how food sits
Food rests on mesh above a solid pan rather than directly on a flat sheet. That arrangement leaves air paths beneath and around the food, while the lower tray catches drips.
For best fit, arrange food with space around pieces instead of crowding the basket; the design depends on airflow, and the product data does not specify a cooking capacity.
A two piece format adds flexibility
The basket and pan work together as an oven air frying set, and the pan can also serve as a baking or roasting surface.
This gives the accessory a broader role than a mesh rack alone, although cooks should check whether their recipes and rack spacing work with its round shape.
Measure before deciding
The listed diameter is 13.12 inches, with intended compatibility across many standard oven racks and smaller convection ovens. Oven interiors vary, so measure the usable rack area rather than relying only on the appliance category.
Account for space to slide the tray in and out with oven mitts.
Care is part of the tradeoff
The titanium and ceramic nonstick coating is intended to help food release, and the parts are described as dishwasher safe.
As with coated cookware generally, buyers should check the included care directions and avoid assuming that every utensil or cleaning method will suit the surface.
Alternatives to Gotham Steel Tray
Grill Baskets alternative

700+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsCave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
Choose the Gotham Steel set for oven-based crisping and its separate catch pan. The Cave Tools basket is a better match when the priority is carrying small foods to an outdoor grill and cooking them over the grates.
- The Cave Tools basket is a rectangular stainless steel grill basket, described for cooking vegetables, fruit, seafood, and meat over a grill; it has a curved handle and is dishwasher safe.
- The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven use and combines a raised mesh basket with a solid pan to catch drips.
Grill Baskets alternative

200+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsKona Smoker & Grill Basket
Pick the Gotham Steel tray for an oven setup with a drip-catching pan. Consider the Kona if your cooking takes place on an outdoor grill or smoker and you want a mesh surface for smaller ingredients.
- The Kona is a 12 by 12 inch nonstick mesh basket intended for outdoor grills and smokers, including cold smoking; its mesh is designed to keep small foods from falling through grill grates.
- The Gotham Steel tray is intended for air frying and other cooking modes in an oven or convection oven.
Is Gotham Steel Tray Worth It?
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if you want an oven accessory that elevates food on mesh and catches drips below.
Its multiple oven uses, coated surfaces, and dishwasher safe construction make it a practical option for cooks who want to try air frying without adding another appliance.
Measure your oven before ordering and be realistic about batch size: a 13.12 inch round tray is only useful if it fits your rack and cooking routine.
For a self-contained appliance, choose a standalone air fryer instead; for outdoor grilling, a grill basket is the more suitable tool.
Your review at a glance

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in an oven or convection oven without adding a standalone air fryer.
- Two piece construction pairs a raised mesh basket with a solid catch pan.
- Round set measures 13.12 inches across and is intended for many standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air fryer models.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating in a copper colored finish.
- Basket and pan are described as dishwasher safe for easier cleanup.